Finding the Best Mattress For You
Everyone has different sleep preferences and there is no one solution for every sleeper. If you are a side, back or the rare stomach sleeper we have solutions for you.
We have compiled a list of the best mattresses we have tested and separated them into different categories to help you choose. The prices listed are before discounts on a queen size mattress, as of 11/14/17.
Top Foam Mattresses 2017
|Foam||92||Layla Review||$899||$60 Off Code NONBIASED60|
|Foam||90||Nectar Review||$795||$125 Off|
|Foam||89||Leesa Review||$940||$100 Off|
|Foam||89||Brooklyn Bedding Review||$750||10% Off & 2 Pillows & Sheets Code Nonbiased10|
|Foam||87||Casper Review||$950||Free Shipping|
|Foam||85||Matsleep Review||$795||$200 off|
|Foam||84||Purple Review||$999||Shop Purple|
|Foam||84||Aloha Sleep Review||$799||Alohalife for $50 Off|
|Foam||81||Live & Sleep Review||$799||$100 NBReviews100|
|Tuft & Needle||Foam||80||Tuft & Needle Review||$675||Free Shipping|
|Foam||78||Bear Review||$940||$50 off|
|Foam||78||Casper Wave Review||$600||Free Shipping|
|Foam||66||Casper Wave Review||$1,850||Free Shipping|
Top Foam Mattresses
|Hybrid||94||Sapira Review||$1475||$100 Off|
|Foam||94||Tomorrow Sleep Review||$980||Nonbiased175 for $175 Off|
|Aurora||Hybrid||93||Aurora Review||$1,699||Nonbiased10 10% Off|
|Hybrid||90||Nest Alexander Review||$1,199||$200 Off Code NONBIASED200|
|Hybrid||88||Helix Review||$995||$100 Off Helix|
|Hybrid||82||Tuck Review||$990||Free Shipping|
|Hybrid||74||Keetsa Review||$786||5% Off|
Top Hybrid (Coils or Innersprings, with Foam) Mattresses1Sapira Hybrid by LeesaA sturdy luxury hybrid mattress. It pulls from many of the things that Leesa does well to form a high end mattress. This mattress is designed to cater to people who feel that the Leesa may have too much sink for them. So if you are an athlete, or on the heavier side, this is a must try!Read full review ConsYou can feel the pocket springs when you sit on the edgeProsCover has the same feel as the LeesaAvena foam layer keeps it coolIndependent pocket springs work well with adjustable framesDesigned for heavier people & athletes, yet soft enough for a petite side sleeper like meThe first bed in a box I have tested without an odor upon openingCoupons & Discount Codes2Tomorrow Sleep Hybrid MattressI'm still shocked that I couldn't find the coil part of the hybrid construction. I'm sleeping better than I have on just about every mattress I have tested this year. Read full review ConsThe corners didn't fill out the cover for 2 daysProsCan't feel the wrapped coil systembacked by serta, warranty and trial period are solidConforms nicely with an adjustable frameTop 2 layers of gel memory foam keep you cool, hug you, and most importantly hide the wrapped coils from you.Take $125 off a purchase of $500 or more3Brooklyn Bedding Aurora HybridAfter more than 2 weeks of sleep testing this, I love it! It's screams luxury, is perfect for an adjustable base, and will provide you with a great sleeping experience.Read full review ConsThe standard brown box that it comes in doesn't scream luxuryPros13.5" of Luxury FeelCool, stretch coverGreat on an adjustable frameNonbiased104Nest Bedding Alexander Signature HybridThey just redesigned the Alexander Signature, I wonder if they are going to add handles to the Hybrid?Read full review ConsThe stitched cover makes it difficult to use on an adjustable frame.ProsSturdy HybridAdded handles to the sides this year!$200 off Alexander Signature5Helix MattressI wish I would have ordered the blended version rather than the dual comfort one.Read full review ConsDual Comfort is a problem if the sides are drastically differentProsCustomizeableCoupons & Discount Codes6Tuck MattressTuck offers so many different features designed just for you. Read full review ConsThe materials surrounding the coils could be better, some of the coils show throughYou can feel the bottom layer of coils when you touch the side of the mattressProsMade with recycled materialsCopper infused memory foamCoupons & Discount Codes
Top Hybrid (Coils or Innersprings, with Foam) Mattresses
Our Testing Criteria
We use 10 categories to rate the mattresses we buy and test.
First Impressions count right? Some of the mattresses come in boxes, and some come in over sized bags. I prefer boxes as they are much easier to move around. Some boxes have cute logos and some have really fun quotes, and yes I really made a video called box vs. box vs. box in a box. Try saying it fast three times in a row. Did you get tongue tied?
On the subject of first impressions, some of the mattresses will have a bit of an odor when they are unboxed. Most people use the term off-gassing to describe it. Some of the mattresses take a few days for the smell to go away and sometimes it is barely noticeable.
When you lay on a mattress and it’s not comfortable that’s surely something that we should point out right?
I have had a ton of mattresses which fail to give me the proper support. There is nothing worse than falling into a deep depression that you have to climb out of. Sometimes you can even get multiple sinking parts and huge mountains in between, clearly not ideal for restful sleep.
Recently we added adjustable base tests to our review process. How do different mattresses stand up to the test?
When testing for this I like to walk on the sides and corners of the mattress.
Sometimes I will sink almost to the floor, which means that if you roll over at night there is a chance you just may fall out of bed!
In the video above you can see how the glass doesn’t move when I walk near it, which is great for when you have a partner who is tossing and turning and not disturbing you. On our scale from 1-10, one is a waterbed, 10 is; wait what? There is someone in the same bed as me!
If I’m not able to sleep on a mattress, then it’s possible that you may have the same issues.
I live in Scottsdale, Arizona and I’ll tell you a little secret about the weather here… It gets hot in the summer. Having a breathable mattress is a must here. There aren’t a ton of things worse than having extra heat rising up from your mattress making your back or side sweat.
Surely what’s inside the mattress matters right? I also pay close attention to the covers.
You really have to look at the prices of the mattress vs. the competition. Not just the direct to consumer, bed in a box model, but the in store values as well. The bed in a box model offers consumers huge cost savings vs. buying from the store. This is because the middle man is cut out and the companies don’t have to pay electricity and rent.
We give each category a score from 1-10 with 10 being the highest. Now that I have tested 23 mattresses this year I have adjusted my scale a bit. I am using a 10 point must system. The mattress that preformed the best in a category gets a 10 and all other mattresses are judged against that standard. Previously some categories didn’t have 10s, as I didn’t want to set anything up as a 10 unless I was sure that it was the best in class.
We also assess the overall firmness of a mattress from 1-10 with 10 being almost rock hard firm. Since different people have different preferences on the firm level that works best for them, that number doesn’t go into the total ratings. Here is our Firmness scale as of 10/4/17
Recently, we noticed that just about every mattress you see in the store is staged on an adjustable frame. These giant retailers must be on to something right? So we decided that every mattress we test should also go through a few cycles of adjustments with our adjustable bed. Currently we are using a Rize Verge. We assume that other adjustable frames will have many of the same characteristics. What we have found is that some mattresses don’t fare well on an adjustable frame, while others take a step up to a new level.
If you haven’t been on an adjustable frame you are really missing out, so we feel that it is crucial to our review process to add this wrinkle. We understand that everyone doesn’t have an adjustable bed, but if you are considering one with your next mattress purchase we feel you should be prepared. If a mattress is too thick or sturdy, it likely won’t preform well on an adjustable base. If it has interlocked coils, forget about it.
Want to do your own comparison? Just drag and drop the mattresses you want to put side by side, from the table below:
Thinking about buying the items we have reviewed? Help Non-Biased Reviews out if you do. Just click on any of the seller links above and the seller will contribute a portion of the sale to help support this site. It won’t cost you anything extra and is a simple way to help us fund more items to review. Thank You